Vol. I  ·  No. 57
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
🔍 Search  ·  278 stories in the archive

Front page › Courts › Nov 11, 2026

Justices Question Labor Department In-House Fines in an H-2A Visa Case

Tuesday's argument in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards could limit agencies' power to impose penalties without a federal court.

The Supreme Court heard argument Tuesday in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, a case over whether the Labor Department can fine an employer through its own administrative judges, rather than in federal court, for breaking promises made to temporary farmworkers admitted on H-2A visas. SCOTUSblog's account says several justices appeared open to limiting that power.

The government argued the dispute falls under "public rights" that Congress may assign to agencies, because it involves both immigration and a government benefit. Chief Justice John Roberts said the case looked "more like a condition of employment rather than … entry." Justice Amy Coney Barrett asked why an alien who violated a visa condition would not be entitled to a court before paying a fine, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh cited Tull v. United States, a precedent from about 40 years ago holding that civil penalties are a common-law remedy for courts.

Justice Elena Kagan said the case fits within existing doctrine, asking whether there was "a condition of entry here." A decision is expected before the term ends next summer.

Sources

Around the table

Corrections, questions and better ways to do it are welcome. No stock tips, no referral links, no selling. Nothing here is individual advice, and neither is anything in the comments. Comments are public and kept until you ask us to remove them.