Supreme Court Will Decide If the President Can Suspend Border Asylum
The justices agreed Friday to review a lower-court ruling against the January 2025 proclamation; the restrictions stay in place while the case goes on.
The Supreme Court on Friday agreed to hear the Trump administration's appeal in Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (No. 26-239), a challenge to the proclamation that suspended access to asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border, SCOTUSblog reports. Argument is likely in the spring of 2027.
The proclamation, signed January 20, 2025, declared that "an invasion is ongoing at the southern border," suspended the entry of noncitizens taking part in it and said they could not seek protections such as asylum. Homeland Security guidance barred noncitizens from applying for asylum and allowed quick removal without some of the procedures set out in federal law.
U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss certified a class of immigrants covered by the proclamation, found the guidance unlawful and barred officials from carrying it out. A panel of the D.C. Circuit largely upheld that ruling, with one judge dissenting in part, but the appeals court has kept its decision on hold during the government's appeal, so the restrictions remain in effect.
Solicitor General D. John Sauer told the justices the policies are among "the most important and effective pieces of the President's response" and rest on the president's power to exclude noncitizens. The challengers argue the president "may not invent by fiat a new removal system," quoting the appeals court. The court also agreed to consider whether Judge Moss could grant class-wide relief, but not whether the class meets class-action rules.
The challengers are represented by lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union and the National Immigrant Justice Center, who call the order an unlawful attempt to unilaterally "eviscerate" legal protections for people fleeing danger and say border crossings were already falling before President Trump took office, the Associated Press reports. Federal lawyers argue that years-long processing times contributed to a major influx of migrants, many of whom were released into the country while awaiting decisions, and that the government should not have to accept applications it would deny. A ruling is expected by the end of June.
It is the third major immigration case the court will hear this term, the AP says. The others ask whether people can be quickly deported to third countries and whether immigrants can be held indefinitely during deportation proceedings. Earlier this year the court sided with the administration in another asylum case, clearing the way for it to potentially revive a "metering" policy used in past years to turn back immigrants.
The same day, the court agreed to hear Robinhood Markets v. Sodha, on when a company can be liable for leaving interim financial results out of its IPO documents.
Sources
- Associated Press, Supreme Court will consider Trump's executive order suspending asylum access at the southern border
- PBS NewsHour (AP), Supreme Court will consider Trump's executive order suspending asylum access at the southern border
- SCOTUSblog, Supreme Court agrees to hear case on Trump administration's suspension of asylum